🚨 Debunking the “Medicaid & SNAP Abuse” Myth 🚨

There’s a growing narrative that Medicaid and SNAP are easy prey to fraud and system abuse—but the truth tells a radically different story. Much of what gets lost amid political rhetoric is that true misuse almost always comes from the providers, not from the families and individuals relying on these programs to survive.

1. Medicaid “Waste”: Mostly Provider-Driven

• According to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, the improper payment rate for Medicaid was 5.1% in 2024—not the exaggerated “20%” often cited. Over 80% of these improper payments stem from missed documentation errors by providers (e.g., billing mistakes), not from beneficiary fraud (CMS, 2024; KFF, 2025)   .

• Anti-fraud experts at Georgetown’s CCf say beneficiary fraud is negligible, comprising only about 2% of convictions and one‑tenth of one percent of recoveries—which underscores how rare it is for recipients to manipulate the system  .

In reality, phony billing schemes, double‑charging, and kickbacks by providers are the real threats—yet these stories rarely infiltrate the headlines  .

⸻

2. SNAP Isn’t an “Easy Ride” for the Unemployed

• Over half of working-age, non-disabled SNAP recipients were employed during the month they received benefits (2015 data)  .

• Census data shows that among the 3.4 million married-couple households on SNAP in 2018, a staggering 84% had at least one worker, and nearly 50% had two or more workers  .

This isn’t sporadic or negligible: SNAP supports millions of working families, not freeloaders.

⸻

3. Attack on School Meals = Attack on Children

Efforts to roll back school breakfast & lunch programs have devastating consequences:

• Community Eligibility Provision (CEP) served over 23 million students in high-poverty schools during 2023–24   . Cutting it forces at least 832,000 children to fill out paperwork just to receive meals—and 18 million students will face higher costs  .

• When universal meals ended after the pandemic, lunch participation dropped 6% and breakfast by 7.7% in just one year—increasing hunger, stigma, and school absences  .

• Consistent research shows hunger worsens academic performance, behavior, attendance, and even mental health (e.g., breakfast boosts math by 17.5%; hungry kids show more disciplinary issues)  .

• Universal school meals also reduce obesity and improve overall health in children  .

⸻

💔 Why This Matters

• Tainting Medicaid & SNAP recipients as abusers is not only factually wrong—it also justifies draconian cuts that hurt vulnerable families.

• School meal cuts don’t just trim budgets. They strip food, dignity, and opportunityfrom millions of children.

✅ Call to Action

1. Stop criminalizing necessity. The real problem in Medicaid is complex billing schemes—not hungry families.

2. Protect SNAP. Working families deserve assistance, not suspicion.

3. Defend school meals. Cutting them is harmful child policy, not fiscal responsibility.

We must challenge misleading narratives and refuse to judge the desperate. Our policies should uplift, not punish, our neighbors in need.

⸻

📚 References (APA 7th)

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2024). 2024 Medicaid & CHIP supplemental improper payment data.

Food Research & Action Center. (2025, March). Proposed cuts to school meals would harm students, families …

Georgetown University CCf. (2025, January 10). The truth about fraud against Medicaid.

Kaiser Family Foundation. (2025, March 18). 5 key facts about Medicaid program integrity…

National Center for Education Statistics. (2023–2024). Community eligibility provision fact sheets.

U.S. Census Bureau. (2018). Most families with SNAP benefits had at least one person working.

U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service. (2024, July 22). Percent of population receiving SNAP benefits in fiscal year 2023.

U.S. Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service. (2015). SNAP provides critical benefits to workers and their families.

U.S. Department of Agriculture Food and Nutrition Service. (2011). Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program impact.

U.S. Department of Agriculture Food and Nutrition Service. (various years). School meal programs in the U.S.

National School Lunch Program data. (2023).